The Supreme Court of the Netherlands has recently ruled that secondment and payrolling are to be considered as temporary employment contracts. This means seconders and payroll employers are allowed to apply a more flexible dismissal regime to temporary employment contracts.
A temporary employment contract is an employment contract where the employee is made available by the employer, in the context of his business activities, to third parties to perform work under the latters’ supervision. It has been unclear for quite some time whether only contracts by “classic” temporary employment agencies were covered by this definition or whether employment contracts by more recent triangle relations, such as seconders and payroll employers could also be considered as temporary employment contracts.
The Dutch Supreme Court has recently determined that the work to be performed for a third party does not have to be temporary for the existence of a temporary employment contract. Pursuant to the Supreme Court, it is not required that the employer fulfils a so-called “allocation function”. For the existence of a temporary employment contract it is therefore not necessary that the employer deals with linking demand and supply of (temporary) work, as “classic” temporary employment agencies do. As a result, secondment and payrolling are also covered by the definition of temporary employment contracts.
As a consequence, seconders and payroll employers can make use of the more flexible dismissal regime that applies to temporary employment contracts, including:
That fact that secondment and payrolling can be considered as temporary employment contracts also means that they will be potentially covered by the (legally binding) ABU collective agreement and the mandatory StiPP pension scheme of the temporary employment industry.
Pursuant to the Supreme Court, it is up to the employer to impose limits to avoid potential negative implications in practice. However, the Supreme Court emphasizes that judges do have the right to suspend the more flexible dismissal scheme for seconders and payroll employers on the basis of reasonableness and fairness.
In short, it seems to have become more attractive to employers to make use of secondment and payrolling for their flexible staff. However, it is perfectly possible that this will be limited by the legislator in the future, or, in individual cases, by a court.
Would you like to get more information on the possibilities of secondment and payrolling? Or do you have any other questions about other forms of flexible employment relationships? Please contact Russell Advocaten:
With the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration again enforcing the Deregulation of Assessment of Employment Relationships Act (DBA Act), these questions have become even more important. In a recent ruling on Uber drivers, the Supreme Court provided additional guidance on how to determine whether someone is a self-employed person.
If employers want to terminate the employment of an employee for poor performance, they need to take a number of steps before they are allowed to do this. Which actions do they have to take? What issues should expats take into account?
The works council has an important task when it comes to working conditions in the company, including social safety. What tools can the works council use to ensure a safe corporate culture?
Losing your job due to redundancy is a bitter experience, especially when you are an expat and may also lose your work permit or residency rights. Which points should you take into account when facing redundancy?
The start of a new year brings not only new resolutions and crowded gyms but also important changes in laws and regulations. This year is no exception, with several significant amendments to employment law that took effect on 1 January 2025. Here, we outline the key points to watch out for as an employer or employee.
The holiday season is approaching, a time of joy and days off for many. However, not everyone finds these holidays equally meaningful.
