Jan Dop

partner

Jan is a specialist in employment law and corporate law

jan.dop@russell.nl
+31 20 301 55 55

Reinier Russell

managing partner

Reinier advises national and international companies

reinier.russell@russell.nl
+31 20 301 55 55

4 tips to prevent extra costs in the event of a dismissal of a director under the articles of association

Publication date 14 May 2019

Exercise due care in the event of a dismissal of the director under the articles of association. A breach of any of the following may lead to the entitlement to a fair compensation. (1) There must be at least one reasonable ground for dismissal. (2) The obligation to reinstatement by the employer continues to apply and may even extend to foreign establishments. (3) The termination bans continue to exist.

ontslag statutair bestuurder - weblijst

A corporate dismissal of the director under the articles of association in principle also includes the termination of the employment contract. This means the rules for dismissal must be taken into account. If this is not the case, there is a risk that the employer might have to pay a fair compensation in addition to the transitional compensation.

When do you have to pay a fair compensation?

There are three situations in which the director under the articles of association can claim a fair compensation.

  1. There is no reasonable ground for dismissal
  2. Infringement of the obligation to reinstatement
  3. The dismissal is the consequence of seriously imputable acts or omissions of the employer.

Amount of fair compensation

When calculating the amount of compensation, the court takes into account, among other things, the income of the director and the damage he is likely to suffer. In principle, the latter will be based on the salary times the expected duration of unemployment. Here it is important that a director cannot claim reinstatement of employment.

How can you prevent having to pay extra compensation?

1. Ensure that there is a reasonable ground for dismissal

Also in the case of the dismissal of a director, one of the legal grounds for dismissal is required. Often the reason for dismissal will be a difference of opinion about the policy to be pursued. The court will rule that this is the case if:

  • The difference of opinion is substantiated by facts.
  • The director is confronted with the difference in vision.
  • There is a concrete indication of the required changes.
  • The difference of opinion continues to exist, for instance because the director refuses to change his approach.

It is advisable to include the reason for dismissal in the dismissal decision or letter of dismissal to prevent discussions about the reason for the dismissal.

2. Comply with the obligation to reinstatement

The dismissal of a director under the articles of association is also subject to an obligation to reinstatement. The employer has a best efforts obligation to investigate whether reinstatement within a reasonable period will be possible. In the event of directors under the articles of association, it is often difficult to find another suitable position within the organisation, in particular if it is a small organisation. If the company is part of a group, other business units must also be considered. In that case, the obligation to reinstatement can also extend to foreign establishments.

The obligation to reinstatement does not mean a job guarantee. There is only a best efforts obligation and an investigation obligation. The employer must prove however that he has complied with these.

3. Be aware of termination bans

Termination bans continue to apply in the event of a dismissal of the director under the articles of association. For example, a director who is ill cannot be dismissed. This termination ban does not apply if the director has called in sick after having received the invitation to the General Meeting of Shareholders (GM) where this item is on the agenda.

4. Observe the notice period

In the event of a dismissal of the director under the articles of association, the notice period that is included in the employment contract or collective agreement must be taken into account. If nothing was agreed in this regard, the statutory notice period will apply. This depends on the duration of the employment.

In the event the notice period is too short, the employer must pay the employee compensation. This is equal to the salary the employee should have received with due observance of the notice period.

More information?

Would you like to get more information about the dismissal of directors under the articles of association of other high-level employees? Do you have other employment law questions? Please contact us:

    We process the personal data above with your permission. You can withdraw your permission at any time. For more information please see our Privacy Statement.

    Related publications

    4 points to consider when dismissing a statutory director

    A statutory director can be both a director and an employee of a company. What are the consequences if a director under the articles of association is dismissed? What do the company and the director have to keep in mind?

    Read more

    Dismissal of statutory director: Don’t forget the dismissal ground!

    It is easy to dismiss a director under the articles of association. However, if he or she is also an employee, regular dismissal law does apply. What do you have to watch out for as an employer?

    Read more

    Statutory director or nominal director?

    Job titles, such as managing director, CEO, director, and authorised director, are common. From a legal point of view there are just two different jobs. So what are the differences and who is authorised to do what?

    Read more

    4 November 2024: Dutch Labour Law Basics for Diplomats

    On Monday 4 November 2024, Russell Advocaten Russell Advocaten will host a seminar on Dutch labour law for diplomats, consular agents, and administrative staff from Embassies and Consulates in collaboration with Diplomat Magazine.

    Read more

    2 October 2024: Labor and Employment Client Seminar by Primerus

    On Wednesday 2 October 2024, Jan Dop will be one of the members of the panel that will present timely labor and employment law issues to Primerus clients.

    Read more

    24 September 2024: Risk management: social media in the company

    On Tuesday 24 September 2024, Reinier Russell and Jan Dop will speak at the Technical Meeting of PAiE, the organisation of professional accountants in Europe.

    Read more